Cypherpunk Bitstream 0x05: Security I
We talk about security and the current state of the security system (police, intelligence services, and the military).
What is security
- 00:02:05 What is security: Security VS Safety.
- Security: unexpected events that go back to an actor,
- Safety: maintaining a status.
- 00:07:20 Entropy: things decay. Security is not a natural state, but must be maintained.
- 00:09:10 Evil people: psychpaths, predators.
- 00:09:50 Circumstances: acting irrationally.
- 00:10:25 Hackers: Red Hats, joy of overcoming security systems.
- 00:11:11 WASP Privilege: no exposure to threats, stuff works most of the time, no incentive to learn about security.
- 00:12:29 High trust society VS low trust society: Low trust comes with high cost and less functional societies.
- 00:16:16 Symptoms of societies with low trust: different environments are what make them.
- 00:16:50 Universal core values of humans: self-preservation, protecting family and friends, private zones, no drama.
- 00:18:05 High trust society needs maintenance, will get eroded quickly by few “bad actors”.
- 00:19:05 How can you turn a low security, low trust environment into a high security, high trust environment? Parallel developments also possible: high security, low trust societies.
- 00:19:40 Trust builds from history of interactions.
- 00:20:13 To change, bad memories must die (social memory). See Thomas Kuhn (1962): The Structure of Scientific Revolutions
- 00:22:10 Western states want to make people dependent on security (stateism) and increase state control. Thus, individuals externalize security, and state is presented as the White Knight.
- 00:25:15 Are we being played/gamed/manipulated by the state and state actors?
- 00:27:38 Just doing our jobs.
- 00:29:50 Machiavellianism: concepts how states can work.
- 00:31:20 Hegelian concepts: totalist and collectivist states and politics.
- 00:33:20 Look at systemic issues.
- 00:33:30 Inspecting institutions: 1) Police.
- 00:39:00 Policemen’s selection bias: everyone is a potential criminal or at least a suspect.
- 00:40:20 Documentation work of police activity by example of firing weapons.
- 00:42:30 Bureaucracy can work.
- 00:47:30 Police in uniform VS civilian police: both are for peace preservation.
- 00:48:00 Military is directed outwards.
- 00:49:00 Carl von Clausewitz: war is the extension of politics [original: war is the continuation of politics by other means].
- 00:49:39 Border guards are the middle layer between military and police (control of territorial boundaries VS maintaining territorial integrity VS maintain security within the borders).
- 00:50:00 Intelligence services:
- Classification: Intelligence service for proper and covert action
- 00:51:00 Similarities and differences to Journalism: Are intelligence services also ad-driven?
- 00:51:48 Intelligence Agencies report only news that can be actionable.
- 00:53:40 Domestic and Foreign Intelligence Services.
- 00:54:20 Objective reporting: Not mission driven, but report driven.
- 00:54:41 Two classes of intelligence services: Report requests coming out of intelligence circle, or mission driven services (Bundesverfassungsschutz, for example).
- 00:56:30 FBI: police organization plus intelligence aspect.
- 00:57:05 Intelligence services are about information, other services are about action.
- 00:57:40 Staatsschutz and German Intelligence: police is for prevent and investigate crimes.
- 00:59:05 Forensics is for police, subversive or maybe illegal actions are for intelligence work. In Germany, it’s clearly seperated; in USA, not so much.
- 01:02:15 CIA: Considered as Intelligence Agency. Gather information is their mandate, not catch criminals.
- 01:05:10 Sending in intelligence to change things: huge toolkit to act available.
- 01:05:50 Intelligence and Military Covert Actions are not Security, but political action. However, it‘s a security issue for the other side.
- 01:06:47 International Security Organizations (Europol, Interpol). No police powers, limited investigation powers.
- 01:08:45 Working groups: example SIS (communicating warrants in EU).
- 01:09:58 Organizations: example Le Circle (high-ranking intelligence chiefs), Munich Security Forum (conference with high-level security chiefs).
- 01:15:00 Why is their image so skewed in the public? (The „Spy Story“)
- 01:18:00 Rubicon Series (2010)
- 01:19:25 CSI Series (2000) - all about forensic analysis of crime scenes, but in reality it‘s not the dominant part, only few questions can be answered.
- 01:21:28 Playbook crime following the standard model VS outliers.
- 01:22:55 Being secretive about methods means keeping the advantage from opponents: intelligence agencies VS intelligence agencies from other countries; police VS criminals.
- 01:23:40 Sources 1) Scientific Fields: Criminalistics, Criminology. (Education Material for people that train police, manuals and coursework can be brought on Amazon, also check out libraries).
- 01:25:34 Sources 2) Reports: Indictments, Warrants (a lot are public, depending on country). Caveat: contains successes and legal processes only.
- 01:27:08 Sources 3) Private Conversation with Policemen, Investigators, Intelligence People to get a more accurate picture about their work.
Public private partnerships
- 01:29:39 Private Security Services.
- 01:30:45 Cybercrime Investigations: Takedown of Cyberpunker 2 (200 servers in a German bunker).
- 01:32:25 Private Companies helping the police in Cybercrime Investigation.
- 01:32:40 Analyzing digital evidence: Given to a lab from a private company. (Cyberforensics, not done by police)
- 01:34:18 White-Collar Crime: Fraud, Commercial Fraud cases etc. Corporate Investigators for hire: Forensic Accountants, etc. (Police work only for special investigator power, or force powers.)
- 01:37:10 Corporations can use private security services when police are bound legally (for example, in bribing), then sanatize the data and give it to the police.
- 01:41:28 Informal communication lines… like in every other industry. (But with special privileges: Police, Military, Intelligence)
- 01:43:04 Presumably Cardinal Richelieu: „If you give me (three, or two) six lines written by the hand of the most honest of men, I will find (seven reasons) something in them which will hang him.“, this quote might be originated by memorialist Françoise Bertraut de Motteville (1723), and was later paraphrased.
- 01:44:46 Real-life cases have a lot of ambiguity going on. It‘s a work of probabilities, not a binary process.
- 01:45:45 Can you cover up a crime as a non-corrupt policeman?
- 01:46:50 Private Security Services exploit the ambiguity of policework (someone bringing you from outside a full case, only verification needed, negative evidence often gets lost).
- 01:48:21 Political Aspect: which crimes are deemed important?
- 01:49:20 Lobbying and capital power: Intellectual Property Crimes.
- 01:50:44 Industry identifies perpretators and delivers them to police.
- 01:50:58 Filesharing: Machine investigating and filing reports, backchanneling, automated sting operation (example, IP-Echelon).
- 01:56:08 Private Agencies provide: Analysis of evidence, production of leads, investigation.
- 01:56:26 Money Laundering: not based on investigative results, but on information provided by for example NGOs (example, Transparency International).
- 01:59:28 Chain Analysis Companies produce risk scores for Cryptocurrency Adresses (public keys).
- 02:01:05 Face recognition to identify suspects: example, Clearview AI (finding people software)
- 02:02:20 Police relies on outside, unchecked influence: Private Actors (non-illegmitate).
- 02:03:25 Recap of Episode:
- What outside input is influencing the police
- Policy definition
- Intelligence field
- 02:04:22 Tax crimes: special investigators who actively try to find criminals.
- 02:04:39 Organized Crime: preventitive task of police (dismantling organizations, Staatsschutz).
- 02:05:35 Civil Disobedience: infiltration by police and private companies.
- 02:07:00 Private Security: 3 categories
- private intelligence services
- private security services
- private military contractors.
- 02:09:38 Private Intelligence is information gathering.
- 02:09:53 Private Intelligence VS corporate espionage.
- 02:11:11 First example.
- 02:15:00 Why is there so much cheap spy tech for sale?
- 02:19:53 Second example: credit suisse incident.
- 02:21:12 Some serious health concerns for the operators and middlemen (in-betweens).
- 02:24:05 Birds of a feather flock together: blurry lines of corporate, state, and private decision makers (different sides of the law).
- 02:26:29 Book/Thesis: Stephan Blancke (2011): Geheimdienstliche Aktivitäten nicht-staatlicher Akteure (private intelligence activities by non-state actors)
- 02:27:11 Private inflitrators, informants and agent provocateurs.
- 02:28:10 Extinction rebellion and very active activists.
- 02:30:30 Capture bounties.
- 02:32:45 A quiet business: private infiltration intelligence services (IMSI-catchers) are often ex police, ex military etc.
- 02:34:40 Sharing information services between intelligence: 4 eyes, 14 eyes.
- 02:38:05 HCPP and game theory: will the cryptoanarchists ever get something done?
- 02:39:00 Today’s security system is like antique byzantine, easy to understand from outside, inside not easy to understand- even for the players themselves.
- 02:40:25 Ross Ulbricht and Silk Road made agents run with money—is it the only case, only in this direction?
- 02:42:00 State systems’ marketing: “protect and serve” by angels? But, ACAB is also wrong.
- 02:45:55 Take personal responsibility for own security.
- 02:48:40 Developments/outlook: technologies that make globalization possible, organizational technologies, reporting and communication.
- 02:50:25 Old days: reporting was sampling (today: big data, AI).
- 02:51:00 New incentive structures: financial markets. Old: financial markets were not global, slow. Today: Global financial markets mean indirect profit from activities like war, markets can be complex, distributed, longer reach.
- 02:52:50 Even dumb criminals can use smart technologies (Dropgangs).
- 02:54:00 The mastermind/ intelligent criminals VS random criminals: attribution becomes problematic (witness problem, no review pointers).
- 02:57:24 Book: Evan Ratliff (2019): The Mastermind. Drugs. Empire. Murder. Betrayal. (Paul LeRoux)
- 03:00:59 Donation Report
- Thomas Kuhn (1962): The Structure of Scientific Revolutions
- Carl von Clausewitz
- Rubicon Series (2010)
- Stephan Blancke (2011): Geheimdienstliche Aktivitäten nicht-staatlicher Akteure (private intelligence activities by non-state actors)
- Evan Ratliff (2019): The Mastermind. Drugs. Empire. Murder. Betrayal. (Paul LeRoux)
We’re on bbs.anarplex.net with our own board to discuss!
Bitstream Scanbox #06965 Ehrenbergstr. 16a 10245 Berlin Germany
Please send us feedback letters, postcards, and interesting books. You can also send us your dirty fiat by cash in the mail! We take all currencies.
Please support Cypherpunk Bitstream by donating to: